Alex Nolan

Email verification fails more often than people think

by

Email verification looks simple on the surface, but in practice it fails more often than many teams expect.

From what I have seen, most issues are not caused by the email service itself, but by how verification systems are designed and tested.

Common failure points:

  • Domains that are silently blocked

  • Messages delayed just long enough to expire

  • OTP codes with very short lifetimes

  • Rate limits that are easy to hit during retries

  • Users refreshing or resubmitting forms too quickly

In many cases, verification links are far more reliable than OTP codes, especially for non-critical accounts.

Curious how others here test or design their email verification flows. What issues have you run into?

13 views

Add a comment

Replies

Best
Alex Nolan

We recently documented a simple checklist we use when testing signup email flows, especially around verification links and OTP behavior.

If anyone is interested, here’s the breakdown:

https://temp-mail.id/email-for-testing