📩 What cold message actually made you reply?

Some time ago I asked here about the worst cold messages you've ever received. The answers were painful and funny at the same time 😅

So now the opposite question.

I get a lot of cold messages every week and ignore most of them. But once in a while one gets through. Usually it's short and clearly written for me and it doesn't ask for a call in the first line.

Sometimes it's one small detail that shows they really looked at what I do. Sometimes it's just a normal human tone in a sea of templates.

What was the last cold message that made you reply? What made it different from the rest?

34 views

Add a comment

Replies

Best

my guess is the ones that mention one specific thing about your work and ask one easy question. in Faraday, the email app we built, emails from real people get their own Human emails section away from newsletters and updates, so a plain personal note like that has a better shot at being seen than a designed one!

The ones I reply to name one specific thing I did and ask one small question I can answer in a line. No call in the first message.

There's research on why those messages are worth writing well. A 2022 Science paper (Rajkumar et al.) used LinkedIn's "People You May Know" experiments across more than 20 million people and found the most job moves came from moderately weak ties: people you share only a few mutual connections with. The slightly cold message to someone at the edge of your network is often the one that changes something.

(I work on LinkedInRank, so I mostly think about this for job seekers writing to recruiters, but it holds for sales too.)

From the sending side, the rule that changed our reply rate most: the first message has no offer at all. Just hello and one question about their work. The offer goes only after they answer, and it's written for what they said, not the template.

It feels slow, two messages before you get to the point. But a pitch in message one gets judged as a pitch, while a question gets judged as a person.

Curious if that holds on your side too: does a message with no ask at all feel more honest, or just vague?

I do not remember the cold message, but they were at maximum for 5 short lines. Pretty direct and straightforward.

Andriana, from the sending side I think the wording matters less than people assume.

The messages of mine that get answered are nearly always about something the person did that week, a comment they left, a role they're hiring for, a post they wrote. There's an obvious reason I'm in their inbox now and not last month. The same short friendly message sent to a job title list mostly gets ignored.

As the one receiving them, does it feel different when someone mentions something recent rather than something off your profile?