Product Hunt's "Visit website" link hides where your sign-ups came from
After our launch on Nov 3 I went looking for how many sign-ups Product Hunt sent us. Our analytics said zero. That seemed wrong, so I checked: the "Visit website" link is marked noreferrer, so visitors arrive without telling your site where they came from. They land in "direct" traffic instead.
If you launched recently, you can't tell your Product Hunt sign-ups apart from people who typed your URL. The fix takes a minute: add ?utm_source=producthunt to your website link. There are two places to change: the launch's links and the product page's website link, which is what the "Visit website" button uses.
We're building NEXUPIRA, an AI team for small businesses, so every sign-up matters to us. Once we looked properly, search turned out to bring us more sign-ups than launch day did.
How do you track where your sign-ups come from? Did launch day or search do more for you?
Edit (Nov 14): Product Hunt now adds utm_source=producthunt to "Visit website" links by default, alongside ref=producthunt. If your link already has its own utm_source, yours takes precedence. Thanks to Mike from the Product Hunt team for shipping this so quickly! Links you share by hand, like the ones in your maker comment, still need their own tag.


Replies
We append a `ref=producthunt` query param to each of the "Visit website" links automatically, too. What could we do here that would feel more intuitive to you?
@mike_ciesielka1 Thanks Mike! you're right, and that one's on us. The ref=producthunt is there. Our sign-up tracking only reads utm_ parameters and the referrer, so it dropped ref, and GA4 ignores ref by default too, which is why it looked like direct traffic. Two things would have saved us: adding utm_source=producthunt next to ref, or
showing the final outgoing URL beside the website field in the launch editor. We're updating our tracking to read ref as well.
@jo_tung_wu yeah we recognize `ref` isn't a standard, and I'd guess that's the reason it was chosen in the first place since it won't conflict with any tracking you already provide in your links (the true rationale has likely been lost to history). maybe a default utm_source like the kind you suggest is a good solve, and if your link provides a different one your value will always take precedence.
@mike_ciesielka1 @mike_ciesielka1 Makes sense, and a default utm_source that defers to the maker's own would solve it neatly. Thanks for considering it! Our tracking now reads ref as well, so we're all set on our end.
@jo_tung_wu You'll see that default utm_source in there now alongside the existing ref param (for folks who already expect it)
@mike_ciesielka1 That was fast, thank you! A default that steps aside for the maker's own utm_source is exactly what we hoped for. I'll update the post so other makers know.
nice that ph shipped the default utm_source that fast. for us search beat launch day too but launch day ppl stuck around way less, so i'd track activation per source not just signups. also check the links in your maker comment, those dont get the param
@bacelj thanks, that's useful. Activation per source makes more sense than raw signups, and I wouldn't have thought about the maker comment links not getting the param. I'll tag those by hand before launch.
@bacelj Great point on activation. Sign-up counts flatter launch day. We're starting to compare activation by source too. How do you define "activated" for Incredible?
Good catch, thanks for sharing!
launching today so this is perfect timing lol. good to know they add utm_source by default now, gonna check tonight if it actually shows up in my analytics
@vidur_saini Good luck with the launch today! When you check tonight, look for source = producthunt in your analytics. If you set your own utm_source on the link, yours wins. Also tag any links you share by hand, like the ones in your maker comment.
Glad the default utm landed so fast. On the search side, the piece analytics can't show you is which query brought the visit, and Search Console at least shows that per page. When we built SEO Radar for PromoPilot, the pattern we kept hitting was that most of the next clicks sit on pages already ranking 4 to 20: Google shows them, they just get few clicks from there.
So if search already beats launch day for you, filtering Search Console by position 4-20 is a cheap next step: those pages already have impressions and only need to move up a few spots.
Where do your search sign-ups land: the homepage, or specific content pages?