Aaron O'Leary

🚨 Landing Page Roast: 48 Hours Only 🚨

A few of us at Product Hunt are putting on our most brutally honest (but helpful!) hats and roasting landing pages for the next two days. Want in? Drop your link below, and we’ll give you real, no-BS feedback on:


🔥 Clarity – Does your message make sense or sound like corporate soup?
🔥 Calls to Action – Do we feel compelled to click, or just… leave?
🔥 Design & UX – Smooth experience or rage quit territory?
🔥 Anything else – Tell us what you want feedback on.


No ego, no fluff—just straight-up advice to make your page better. Drop your link below 👇

6K views

Add a comment

Replies

Best
Tania Bell
Ben Griese

@taniabell I'm unsure if it's a product or a project management service? Deliberately focusing on how it's a tech-related product and highlighting those features could be helpful!

steve beyatte

@taniabell 

  • Using Dropbox/Zappos logos feels disingenuous

  • I'd be more inclined to trust this page if you showed case studies of real results

Tania Bell

@ben_griese thanks for your feedback. what makes you think that this could be a project management service?


btw, it's a product management service.

Tania Bell

@steveb thank you for your feedback.


the logos support and illustrate the point I'm making, nothing else.


real results are showcased and testimonials provided

Catalin Zorzini

thank you, here's us: ai-tutor.ai

steve beyatte

@zorzini 

  • Cool, I like this

  • Wait, now I'm confused. I thought this was personalized online learning but I clicked "Fundamentals of Machine Learning for Beginners" and I expected to get ask something about how I learn or some way to personalize it

  • Product looks cool but I had to click in and sign up to find out I can't personalize courses on a free plan. All I wanted to know was how it does it because the landing page doesn't say anything about it except "Our AI system assesses your learning style, strengths and weaknesses to customize lessons and practice exercises." To me, this is the USP and should be the focus of the landing page.

Eivind Håverstad
Podbooster.io
steve beyatte

@eivindhaa 

  • This is pretty good.

  • How about case studies to prove how you make graphs go up?

  • How about showing off content created with podbooster?

Vishakha Gupta

Looking forward to learn from the responses. Thank you!

Here's ours - https://www.aperturedata.io/

steve beyatte

@vishakha_gupta4 

  • I know what all of the words on the hero mean but I still don't know what you do

  • "Managing Multimodal Data For AI Is Hard" - what's hard about it? Who has this problem?

  • For all things infra, social proof and answering "are you going to be around tomorrow" becomes really important. Feels pretty sparse

  • I am confused generally where this fits into my stack and what i can do with it

Vishakha Gupta

@steveb thank you for the feedback which is quite on point. It is something we are actively working on figuring out how to capture.

Sarah Shaiq

Here's mine: rosey.ai

Thanks for the help!

steve beyatte

@techgoddess 

  • What does this do that Google Cal doesn't do?

  • I want to see the product

  • I want to see examples esp. stuff unique to Rosey

Sarah Shaiq

@steveb thanks Steve! Appreciate the input, some stuff to think through.

Oliver

boostyour.email


Shoot 😉 (will soon be replaced with the real-deal…)

steve beyatte

@digimarkethingz 

  • "A digital marketing tool to help you send captivating emails." is the only part that made sense to me

  • Having a little tool that I can type into to use the tool would be awesome but it's just a gif

  • Excited for the launch!

Oliver

@steveb thank you! 🫶

Colin Mathews

Thanks for this opportunity -- please, please do me! https://futurezapp.com

steve beyatte

@colinmathews 

  • This is cool and interesting

  • I don't like the headline because it only speaks to people who have money issues which are less likely to be the ones who spend money on finance apps, "Is being uncertain about money holding you back?"

  • Are you connecting to my banks? or I am just inputting data?

  • The samples page doesn't have anything that would interest me and I'm interested in pretty much anything in this sphere. All buy vs rent calculators, retirement calculators, etc. are wrong. This could do it so much better.

Colin Mathews

@steveb Thank you - this is great feedback! No, it's not connecting to any banks; just taking inputs.


That's really helpful on the samples not being interesting. Maybe they don't come across as personal, or don't convey a sense of urgency. The goal was to inspire the visitor into thinking of how they'd use it, but I wonder if they would be more useful in an education context, instead of as marketing.


If you think of something you'd have liked to see that could have led you to an a-ha moment, please let me know! Thanks again -- 🙏🏻

Richard Ouellet

Great idea!

I'd love to get your honest feedback on Superfan Share!

It's a platform that helps creators and brands incentivize their fans to share content in exchange for rewards. We're also developing a URL shortener that will be included with all plans and available as a standalone product.

I'm especially curious about whether the value proposition is clear and if the design feels engaging.

Here's the link: https://superfanshare.com

Looking forward to your thoughts — no BS needed!

steve beyatte

@richard_ouellet1 

  • There's so much fluff here. I didn't read your comment here, went to the website and I am 30 seconds into the video and it's still all nebulous fluff.

  • Even after reading the lower part of the website, I still have no idea

  • Try rewriting copy the same way you'd tell a friend what you're doing. If I asked someone what they do and they said they "Supercharge Your Growth Turn Visitors into Your Biggest Promoters" I would not get it

Richard Ouellet

@steveb 

Thanks!

You just confirmed what I thought, I am getting decent traffic but the conversion rate is abnormally low.

Harriet Morton-Liddle
steve beyatte

@harriet_morton_liddle 

  • This is interesting

  • £25/year feels like it may be too cheap?

  • It seems like the crux is that you give people data and templates on how to negotiate better leave in the UK, is that right?

  • There's a lot of design areas that feel really cramped an then a lot that have a ton of whitespace

  • Overall this feels pretty good!

  • Weird image overlay bug:


Harriet Morton-Liddle

@steveb Thanks appreciate it!

Yeah we have a database of parental leave policies to help people negotiate but we also have our membership which a community as well as access to masterclasses where we deep dive on topics specific to maternity pay in the uk.

Pricing is something we are working on the moment. Due to the topic we are discussing (maternity pay/parental pay) the price is a sticky point as people dont want to pay/grumble when they have to pay.

Appreciate the feedback and thanks for highlighting the overlay bug!


Paul Li

IDE for vibe coders
Have no mercy

Aaron O'Leary

@eleven59 this is great! I genuinely love it, I love how it's so simple! Immediately knew what it was all about

steve beyatte

@eleven59 

  • I waitlisted

  • This is very good

  • Company name cheapens the brand IMO

  • I think it's interesting to do an IDE specifically for a niche but that's probably where we're headed

  • Will keep my eyes out for the "Supabase acquires EasyCode Flow" post in 3 years

  • Very clear landing page

First
Previous
•••
789
•••
Next
Last