How do you give feedback to a player without it feeling like a judgment?

by•

We are working on a game that scores how well you copy a sound on a 0 to 100 scale, and the hardest design problem has not been the scoring itself. It is the tone of the feedback. A bare "42" in front of your friends can feel like a verdict, while the same number with a playful line next to it gets a laugh.

What we found so far: breaking the score into a few parts (rhythm, pitch, loudness) helps, because players blame the part and not themselves. Letting people pick how blunt the feedback is also helps, since a family table wants gentle and a group of friends wants roasting. And a low score should always come with something specific to try next.

For anyone building apps or games with scoring, ratings or critique: how do you keep feedback honest without making people feel judged? Any examples of products that do this well?

1 view

Add a comment

Replies

Be the first to reply

Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.