How do you make a game's "roast" feature funny without it being mean?

by•

We have been experimenting with feedback that is deliberately a bit cheeky, the kind of playful teasing you would get from a friend at a party, and it is harder than it looks. A few things we have learned so far: the joke should always be about the performance, never about the person; it should land after something clearly silly rather than after a sincere attempt; and a friendly follow-up line right after the tease changes the whole mood. We also found that the same line reads very differently when a group hears it together versus one person alone on a screen. The open question: where do you draw the line between a playful roast and something that makes a player want to quit? If you have shipped or played anything with humorous feedback, what worked and what backfired?

3 views

Add a comment

Replies

Be the first to reply

Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.