Our free tier grew 400% this year. We just realized it's costing us more than our paid tier makes.
When we launched our B2B SaaS, we were proud of our freemium model. We offered a robust free tier to get people in the door, build word-of-mouth, and create a massive top-of-funnel. It worked—our free user base grew by 400% this year, and our brand awareness skyrocketed.
But last week, I finally did the math, and the numbers are terrifying:
Our 4,000 free users are costing us $2,800/month in server and database costs. They are storing massive files and making heavy API calls.
Our 200 paid users are generating $3,200/month in revenue.
Our conversion rate from free to paid is sitting at a pathetic 1.8%.
We are essentially running a free hosting service for 4,000 people, funded entirely by the 200 paying customers who are subsidizing them. Worse, our free users are flooding our support inbox with basic questions, slowing down response times for our paying customers and burning out our small team.
I realized our free tier is just too generous. We gave away the farm, and now we're trapped. If we tighten the free tier (reduce limits, remove features, or add a credit card requirement), we risk a massive backlash and a PR nightmare. But if we don't, we might run out of cash.
For founders who have had to tighten a generous free tier: How did you do it without destroying your brand or causing mass churn?
Did you grandfather existing free users and only apply the new limits to new signups? Did you just rip the band-aid off and accept the outrage? I need to figure out how to fix our unit economics before it's too late.
p/airuncode
p/runevr
p/producthunt
p/google-cloud-platform
p/aperture-7
p/kodlo
p/raycast
p/ai-context-flow
p/kuc-kuc
p/lasso-11
p/offiai
p/dino-kids
p/many-displays
p/supabase
p/jev
p/reso
p/dex-by-exmergo
p/murror
p/htmldrag
p/nexupira
Replies
Be the first to reply
Have a question or a thought to share? Add a comment above to start the conversation.