Happy to provide the first review!
They scrape my (and your) public github data and created a false representation of who I was (slapped the wrong countries flag on my profile), they claim to have no way to opt out and prevent my data from appearing on their servers. Cold emailed me with the data they harvested and refused to acknowledge any wrong doing, what a wonderful product, illegal by design it seems!
When asked why they wouldn't delete my data, they said their platform wasn't built that way.
They've left me waiting for 28 days for a resolution to my request for the right to be deleted, I'm really looking forward to the clock hitting 30 days so I can let github know they have improperly processed data and let their respective data controller know.
the part I'd want to understand before trusting a score is what it does to someone who does great work at a company with a private repo all day and only pushes weekend side projects publicly, versus someone who commits noisy formatting changes and doc typo fixes to public repos constantly. public GitHub activity correlates with output but it also correlates with how much of your job happens to be open source. does the scoring try to normalize for that at all, or is it explicitly "public output only, make your peace with it"?
@galdayan Thats a legitimate concern including maybe people who will maybe now buy stars
But I think the algorithm can be improved and I was on, Most non noisy high ranking public contributors also do great work at a company
And for example if private repos were to be in the equation, the calibration will just change
Happy to hear what you think
@olebogeng_mbedzi fair enough - "make your peace with public output only" is at least an honest constraint to state upfront rather than pretending the score is a full picture of someone's engineering ability. would rather see that caveat on the card itself than have a client assume it's comprehensive
@galdayan Thanks a lot for this feedback, I will definitely have this implemented
honestly the player card idea is kind of fun, made browsing way more engaging than another boring list. plain english search worked pretty well when i tried it too.
the oauth integration makes this a really smooth experience and the github stats base the profile in reality, well done.
@salah_zeghdani Thanks a lot for th feedback
The player card scoring idea feels genuinely fresh, like turning GitHub activity into something you'd actually want to browse rather than another dry analytics dashboard.