🔥 Roast my idea: drop your ideas and get brutally honest feedback 🔥
by•
It's simple. Drop your next big idea and get some brutally honest but hopefully valuable feedback. The rules are:
Drop your idea, you don't have to go super in depth but give a sentence or two about what it is and does.
Get roasted, duh
Roast someone else's.
That way we create a cycle of feedback
2K views
Replies
Fireapis
A local dev platform for developing total backend that's fully managed by AI from coding, testing & till deploying it. Currently in beta stage https://pipet.dev
I’m thinking build ChessVanguard – a platform to help beginners learn chess through interactive lessons, live coaching, and progress tracking. Would love your thoughts:
Free/paid tiers: Basic puzzles vs. full coaching
Clickable lessons: Learn by playing moves on a board
Coach tools: Annotate games and track student progress
I want to hear your brutally honest feedback regarding the platform and whether that will work, and I want to validate this idea with real users' feedback.
I have recipes everywhere, if not from a special map on my social media, to blog sites and hundreds of pieces of paper. I am currently working towards making this all into one platform as your own personal cookbook to eat better and with more variety.
A fitness app that is also able to curate workouts to you, suggest improvements and analyse your past workouts to maximise your progress towards your goal. To make it unique, you are able to post your own workout split onto the app, and other users can upvote it, similar to product hunt, and the highest upvoted every week wins a cash prize – blending fitness and community like never before. Check it out at smartsplitapp.com!
@lord_hari I like the way you present things, like gamifying a bit more the overly saturated workout apps field. Emphasizing the community aspect and challenging people...
That would be refreshing!
A privacy first budgeting app that keeps all user spending related data and budget information on the local device (with options for encrypted syncing). It scans receipts and categorizes line items into budget categories, instead of connecting directly with banks.
Plateful is a lightweight analytics tool for small restaurants and bars. Owners can upload their daily sales reports (from PetPooja, Menson, or even just a photo of sales receipt), and the tool returns actionable insights like which dishes sell best on weekends, ideal price points, combo suggestions, and inventory planning tips. Think of it as a super simple "AI manager" for folks who can't afford business analysts.
I am developing a mobile app where you can:
Speak a thought - it turns into a reminder
Take a photo or screenshot - it reads the text and sets a reminder
Set location-based alerts (like: remind me when I’m near a grocery store)
All works online and offline.
It tries to figure out the reminder content automatically from whatever you give it (voice or image), so you don't waste time typing.
Would appreciate any thoughts or brutal feedback! Would you use it?
@ivan_otrigko Hello! It is a great idea. It is a little bit like Siri/ Ok Google but they do not provide location based alerts if I am not wrong. I would use it. The only thing is it should be simple to understand and use.
@ivan_otrigko Nice idea! I used to think about something a bit similar for my grocery list. Like planning where are the vegetables, the meat, the cheese in a supermarket using geolocation and computing the shortest path possible depending on that.
That may a bit too niche or a bit unrelated to your initial idea anyway.
I hate spending too much time in supermarket haha
Hey everyone, I'm working on a SaaS product that makes it easy for small businesses to run ads on a budget. Here's the URL. Essentially, you paste a URL, pay, and we'll run ads for you, then provide a real-time dashboard with analytics and recommendations from our AI agent (think Grok). My target audience is US businesses, I've found that local agencies typically don't want to work with budgets under $5k.
Feedback welcome!
I created a Echo Now AI, Slack AI assistant to not get lost in Slack messages. It's a free (with limits) alternative for Slack AI. You can use it for:
Daily summary of activity from all channels you are in
Quick on-demand channel summary of messages from last 24 hours
Chatbot with context of last 50 messages from the channel
Quick summary of long thread via Slack shortcut
When I was searching for Slack AI alternatives, I didn't find anything useful, so I decided to create one.
My idea is a game app that turns real-life hangouts into chaotic, competitive fun. Teams get generated challenges like “Take a photo with a stranger named James,” “Do a cartwheel in a store aisle,” or “Eat a food starting with Z.” With a live leaderboard, time limits, and customizable difficulty, it’s made for spontaneous hangouts, parties, and even corporate team-building.
Roast it and let me know what’s missing or what could be improved!